Fish Bueno Fishing Derby Rules

Explore the world of Dorado through species information, fishing adventures, techniques, recipes, and stories from the water.

Fish Bueno Derby Rules

Fishing doesn’t always go according to plan — but the Fish Bueno Derby Rules keep things fair, simple, and fun.

These rules are used for Fish Bueno Challenges and friendly competitions on the water.  Check event pages for specific rules for that event.

The goal is simple:

Go fishing. Catch fish. Stack points.

1. Eligible Fishing Methods

All fish must be caught using rod and reel.

Allowed platforms include:

  • Kayak

  • Boat

  • Shore/Jetty

  • Pier

  • Jet Ski/SeaDoo

  • Float tube

If your line hit the water, you’re in the game.

2. Proof of Catch

Every fish counted in the derby must have visual proof.

Acceptable proof includes:

  • Photo of the fish

  • Video footage of the catch

  • Photo showing the fish with the angler

Photos should clearly show the species and approximate size.

* Bonus points may be awarded for great fishing photos.

3. Measurement

Fish are scored primarily by species points, not length.

However:

  • Longest fish may be used to break ties

  • Measurement photos are encouraged when possible

4. Catch Legality

Fish do not need to be legal size to count toward derby points.

Because in fishing:

If you caught it — it still counts.

However, fish that meet legal size requirements earn a legal catch bonus.

All anglers must still follow local fishing regulations, including required releases.

5. Honor System

The Fish Bueno Derby operates on the angler honor system.

That means:

  • No misidentifying species

  • No using old photos

  • No funny business

Fishing is supposed to be fun. Keep it honest.

6. Scoring

Each species earns a set number of points.

Example scoring:

SpeciesPoints
Tuna50
Yellowtail10
Halibut9
White Seabass9
Sheephead7
Calico Bass6
Bonito5
Barracuda4
Spotted Bay Bass3
Rockfish2
Mackerel2
Croaker2
Perch2
Everything Else2
Jacksmelt1
Lizardfish / Rays / Shark0

 

Legal Fish Bonus:
Fish that meet legal size requirements receive +2 bonus points.  Fish with no limit size receive no bonus

Points accumulate throughout the challenge.

The angler with the highest total points wins.

7. Upgrade Rule

Only the best fish of each species counts.

If an angler catches a better fish of the same species later in the challenge, it replaces the previous one.

This keeps the derby competitive until the final cast.

8. Optional Challenge Rules

Individual Fish Bueno challenges may introduce additional rules such as:

Target Species Bonus

A designated species may earn additional bonus points for the challenge.

Time Limit

Challenges may run for a specific time period such as:

  • 2 hours

  • 24 hours

  • one fishing trip

Any special rules will be announced at the start of the challenge.

9. The Bueno Rule

Fishing rarely goes exactly as planned.

The fish might be small.
The target species might not show up.
The best part of the day might be tacos after the trip.

But if you got out there and caught something…

It still counts.

And if it’s legal…

even better.